The latest

Karie holding a platter of cupcakes

Welcome to Butter Witch!

I’m Karie, a former pastry chef and farmer. I like to share unique baking recipes inspired by the seasons, with a special emphasis on foraged ingredients. Let’s bake!

Favorite fall recipes

Baking with winter squash

What are you craving?

Cinnamon roll season!


A green tomato hand pie broken open to show inside

Try something new: Green Tomato Hand Pies

You won’t believe these charming hand pies are made with tomatoes! Unripe tomatoes are disguised as apple pie in this vintage southern classic.


Karie’s current faves